Have you ever looked at your 457 plan and wondered how much of that hard-earned money will actually end up in your pocket after taxes? If you’re like many government or non-profit workers, you’ve poured years into building this nest egg.
But when withdrawal time comes, Uncle Sam wants his share. The good news? There are legal ways to minimize or even avoid some taxes on those withdrawals. We’ll break it down step by step, so you can make informed choices without feeling overwhelmed.
Table of Contents
What Exactly Is a 457 Plan?
A 457 plan is a type of retirement savings account offered mainly to state and local government employees, plus some non-profit workers.
Think of it as a cousin to the 401(k), but with a few unique twists. You contribute pre-tax dollars, which grow tax-deferred until you pull them out.
One big perk? Unlike traditional 401(k)s or IRAs, 457 plans don’t slap you with a 10% early withdrawal penalty if you leave your job before age 59½. That flexibility can be a lifesaver during career changes or early retirement.
But remember, while penalties might be off the table, income taxes aren’t. Withdrawals count as ordinary income, so your tax bracket at the time matters a lot.
If you’re in a higher bracket when you withdraw, you’ll pay more. That’s why planning ahead is key. Curious about how much tax you might face?
It depends on your total income, but federal rates can range from 10% to 37%, plus state taxes in many places.
Why Do 457 Withdrawals Get Taxed?
Taxes on 457 withdrawals stem from the plan’s design. Your contributions go in before taxes, lowering your taxable income back then.
The IRS lets your money grow without annual taxes, but they get their cut when you take distributions. It’s like a deferred bill that comes due later.
For most folks, withdrawals after separation from service are straightforward but fully taxable. If you’re still working, rules get stricter, often requiring “unforeseeable emergencies” to access funds without issues. Even then, taxes apply.
The silver lining? No required minimum distributions (RMDs) until you actually retire or separate, unlike some other plans starting at age 73. This gives you more control over timing, which is huge for tax planning.
Key Strategies to Minimize Taxes on Your 457 Withdrawal
Want to keep taxes low? It’s all about strategy. You can’t dodge taxes entirely (that’s illegal), but you can reduce them smartly. Here are some proven approaches.
Time Your Withdrawals Wisely
One of the simplest ways is to withdraw when your income is lower. Say you retire early or have a gap year, your tax bracket might drop, meaning less tax on each dollar pulled from your 457.
For example, if you’re in the 24% bracket now but expect to be in 12% later, waiting could save you big. Spread withdrawals over years to avoid bumping yourself into a higher bracket. This is called income smoothing, and it’s a classic move.
Roll Over to Another Retirement Account
Rolling your 457 into an IRA or another qualified plan can delay taxes. A direct rollover to a traditional IRA keeps the tax-deferred status intact. You won’t pay taxes until you withdraw from the IRA.
What about a Roth IRA rollover? That’s a conversion, where you pay taxes now on the amount rolled over, but future withdrawals are tax-free if rules are followed.
If you think tax rates will rise or you’ll be in a higher bracket later, this could be a winner.
Just note: 457 plans from governmental employers can roll to Roth IRAs, but non-governmental ones might have limits. Check your plan details.
Consider a Roth 457 Option If Available
Some employers offer Roth 457(b) accounts. Here, you contribute after-tax dollars, so withdrawals (including earnings) are tax-free after age 59½ and five years in the plan.
If your plan has this, max it out. It’s like front-loading taxes for back-end freedom. Not all plans do, though, ask your HR department.
Use Net Unrealized Appreciation (NUA) for Company Stock
If your 457 holds employer stock, NUA might apply. This lets you take stock distributions at cost basis, taxing only the appreciation as capital gains later (at lower rates than ordinary income).
It’s niche, but powerful if your plan includes stock. Capital gains top out at 20%, versus 37% for income tax.
Deduct Medical Expenses or Charitable Contributions
Withdrawals are income, but you can offset taxes with deductions. High medical bills? Itemize them if over 7.5% of adjusted gross income.
Or, make qualified charitable distributions (QCDs) if you’ve rolled to an IRA. QCDs send money directly to charity, counting toward RMDs without adding to taxable income. Not direct from 457, but post-rollover, it’s an option.
State Tax Considerations
Don’t forget states. Some, like California, tax 457 withdrawals fully. Others, like Florida, have no state income tax. If relocating, factor this in.
A quick table to compare:
| State Example | Tax on 457 Withdrawals? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| California | Yes | Up to 13.3% |
| Texas | No | No state income tax |
| New York | Yes | Up to 10.9% |
This isn’t exhaustive, your state might differ.
Common Pitfalls to Watch Out For
Even with smart plans, mistakes happen. One biggie: Forgetting about withholding. Plans often withhold 20% federal tax automatically, but if you’re in a higher bracket, you might owe more come April.
Another? Mixing up governmental vs. non-governmental 457s. Non-governmental ones can’t roll to IRAs easily and might have creditor risks.
Always document everything. The IRS loves records, especially for rollovers.
If you’re under 59½ and still employed, emergency withdrawals are limited, don’t count on them lightly.
FAQs: How to Avoid Tax on 457 Withdrawal
Q. Can I completely avoid taxes on my 457 withdrawal?
A. No, not entirely, as withdrawals are generally taxable income. But strategies like Roth conversions or timing can minimize or defer taxes significantly.
Q. What’s the best time to withdraw from a 457 plan?
A. Ideally, when your overall income is low, like early retirement years, to stay in a lower tax bracket. Avoid lumping sums that push you higher.
Q. Do I need to take RMDs from a 457 plan?
A. Not while employed, but after separation or age 73 (as of 2023 rules, potentially updating), yes. Rolling to an IRA might change this.
Conclusion
Navigating taxes on 457 withdrawals doesn’t have to be a headache. By timing smartly, considering rollovers, and exploring Roth options, you can keep more of your savings.
Remember, every situation is unique, what works for one person might not for another. Start by reviewing your plan statement and crunching numbers.
Disclaimer: This blog is for informational purposes only and isn’t personalized tax advice. Consult a qualified tax professional or financial advisor before making decisions, as tax laws can change.
About The Author
