Dental care can be expensive. From routine cleanings to unexpected procedures like root canals, the costs add up fast. So, it’s no surprise that many people wonder, “Can you have two dental insurance policies?” The short answer is yes, you can! But there’s more to it than just signing up for two plans.
What Is Dual Dental Insurance?
Dual dental insurance means having two separate dental insurance plans at the same time.
Table of Contents
For example, you might have one plan through your employer and another through your spouse’s employer. Or maybe you have a primary plan and buy a secondary one privately.
The goal? To cover more of your dental expenses and reduce what you pay out of pocket.
Having two plans doesn’t mean double the benefits automatically. Instead, the two plans work together through a process called coordination of benefits.
This ensures you don’t get paid more than the actual cost of your dental care. Sounds simple, right? Let’s break it down further.
How Does Dual Dental Insurance Work?
When you have two dental insurance policies, one is considered the primary plan, and the other is the secondary plan.
The primary plan pays first, covering as much as it allows under its terms. Then, the secondary plan kicks in to cover some or all of the remaining costs, depending on its rules.
Here’s a quick look at how it typically works:
- Primary Plan: Pays first, based on its coverage limits and rules.
- Secondary Plan: Pays after the primary plan, often covering copays, deductibles, or procedures the primary plan didn’t fully cover.
- Coordination of Benefits (COB): This is the process insurers use to decide who pays what. It prevents you from profiting from dental care (you can’t get paid more than the bill).
For example, if a procedure costs $1,000, your primary plan might cover $600. The secondary plan could then cover part or all of the remaining $400, depending on its terms.
Why Would You Want Two Dental Insurance Policies?
You might be thinking, “Why bother with two plans?” Great question!
Here are some reasons people opt for dual coverage:
- Lower Out-of-Pocket Costs: Two plans can reduce what you pay for copays, deductibles, or uncovered services.
- More Coverage for Expensive Procedures: Major dental work like crowns, bridges, or implants can cost thousands. Dual coverage may help offset these costs.
- Access to Different Networks: One plan might have a dentist you love, while the other covers specialists or additional services.
- Maximize Benefits: If one plan has a low annual maximum (say, $1,000), a second plan can pick up where the first one stops.
But it’s not all sunshine and smiles. There are some downsides to consider, which we’ll cover later.
How to Determine Your Primary and Secondary Plans
Figuring out which plan is primary and which is secondary depends on a few factors. Insurance companies follow standard rules to decide this.
Here’s how it usually goes:
| Situation | Primary Plan | Secondary Plan |
|---|---|---|
| You have coverage through your job and your spouse’s job | Your employer’s plan | Your spouse’s plan |
| You’re a dependent on a parent’s plan | Parent’s plan (based on birthday rule) | Other parent’s plan or your own |
| You buy a private plan | Employer plan (if applicable) | Private plan |
The “birthday rule” often applies for dependents. The parent whose birthday comes first in the year (by month and day, not age) has the primary plan.
For example, if Mom’s birthday is March 10 and Dad’s is June 15, Mom’s plan is primary.
Benefits of Having Two Dental Insurance Policies
Dual coverage can feel like a financial safety net.
Here’s why it might make sense for you:
- Reduced Costs: You could pay less for procedures like fillings, crowns, or orthodontics.
- Broader Coverage: Some plans don’t cover certain treatments (like cosmetic dentistry). A second plan might fill those gaps.
- Higher Annual Maximums: If one plan caps at $1,500 per year, a second plan might cover additional costs after you hit that limit.
- Flexibility with Providers: You can choose dentists from either plan’s network, giving you more options.
For example, let’s say you need braces, which cost $5,000. Your primary plan covers $2,000, and your secondary plan covers another $1,500. You’re only left with $1,500 to pay out of pocket instead of the full amount.
Drawbacks of Dual Dental Insurance
Before you rush to sign up for a second plan, consider the potential downsides:
- Extra Premiums: Two plans mean two sets of monthly premiums. Make sure the savings outweigh the costs.
- Complexity: Coordination of benefits can be confusing. You might need to deal with more paperwork or disputes between insurers.
- Diminishing Returns: Some secondary plans only cover a small portion of remaining costs, so the extra premium might not be worth it.
- Network Restrictions: You may still be limited to in-network dentists, depending on both plans’ rules.
It’s a balancing act. Weigh the costs of premiums against the potential savings on dental care.
Types of Dental Insurance Plans
Not all dental plans are the same. Understanding the types can help you decide if dual coverage is worth it.
Here are the main types:
- PPO (Preferred Provider Organization): Offers flexibility to see in-network or out-of-network dentists, but in-network care is cheaper.
- HMO (Health Maintenance Organization): Requires you to use in-network dentists and may have stricter coverage rules.
- Indemnity Plans: Pay a percentage of your dental costs, regardless of the provider, but may have higher premiums.
- Discount Plans: Not true insurance, but they offer discounted rates at participating dentists.
If you have a PPO and an HMO, for example, the PPO might be primary and give you more provider choices, while the HMO could cover specific services at a lower cost.
When Dual Dental Insurance Makes Sense
Dual coverage isn’t for everyone.
It’s most helpful in these situations:
- You have high dental expenses (e.g., ongoing orthodontic work or multiple procedures).
- Your primary plan has a low annual maximum or limited coverage.
- You want access to a broader network of dentists.
- You’re a dependent covered by two parents’ plans or a spouse’s plan.
If you only go for cleanings twice a year, a second plan might not be worth the extra cost.
How to Get Dual Dental Insurance
Ready to explore dual coverage?
Here’s how to get started:
- Check Existing Coverage: Review your current plan’s benefits, annual maximum, and network. See what gaps you need to fill.
- Explore Secondary Options: Look into plans through your spouse, a private insurer, or even a dental discount plan.
- Compare Costs: Calculate the premiums for a second plan and estimate your potential savings on dental care.
- Talk to Insurers: Ask both insurance companies how they handle coordination of benefits to avoid surprises.
- Enroll Carefully: Make sure you understand the terms of both plans before signing up.
FAQs: Can You Have Two Dental Insurance Policies
Q. Can you use two dental insurance plans at the same time?
A. Yes, you can use two plans through coordination of benefits. The primary plan pays first, and the secondary plan covers remaining eligible costs.
Q. Does having two dental plans double my benefits?
A. No, you can’t double your benefits. The plans work together to cover costs up to the procedure’s total cost, not beyond it.
Q. How do I know which plan is primary?
A. The primary plan is usually the one through your employer or, for dependents, the plan of the parent with the earlier birthday. Check with your insurer for specifics.
Q. Is dual dental insurance worth the cost?
A. It depends on your dental needs. If you have high expenses or need major procedures, dual coverage can save money. For routine care, it might not be worth the extra premiums.
Conclusion
Having two dental insurance policies can be a smart way to save on dental care, especially if you face high costs or need extensive work. By understanding how primary and secondary plans work together, you can make the most of your coverage.
However, weigh the pros and cons carefully. The extra premiums and paperwork might not always be worth it for everyone. If you’re considering dual coverage, review your current plan, compare options, and talk to your insurers to make an informed decision.
A little planning now can lead to a healthier smile and a lighter wallet hit later.
Disclaimer: This blog is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or insurance advice. Consult with your insurance provider or a financial advisor to determine the best dental insurance options for your needs.
About The Author
